16th October 2026
STOCKPORT LOCAL PLAN
REGULATION 19 REPRESENTATION
PADDEN BROOK, ROMILEY
Representation: OBJECTION
Introduction
I wish to make a formal representation in relation to the proposed planning approach to land at Padden Brook, Romiley, and ask that the Council and, subsequently, the appointed Planning Inspector give careful consideration to the site’s particular planning, environmental, ecological, land-stability and enforcement history.
This representation is concerned not simply with the principle of development but with whether the planning framework affecting Padden Brook is based upon a complete, accurate and sufficiently robust understanding of the site’s constraints and existing protected status.
The evidence available indicates that the woodland at Padden Brook is subject to multiple forms of protection and that significant questions remain concerning the condition and stability of the land, a retaining wall serving neighbouring properties, drainage and surface water, ecological impacts, tree loss and the cumulative effect of successive changes to the site.
The Council’s own current records confirm that Tree Preservation Order 376E – Padden Brook, Romiley 2023 remains active, having been made on 16 May 2023 and confirmed on 16 November 2023.
The Council’s own correspondence reproduced in the Padden Brook record has also been reported as confirming that the woodland is a Local Wildlife Site, is subject to W1 woodland protection, and was historically identified as protected visual-amenity land associated with the 1960s development permission.
These matters should be treated as substantive planning considerations rather than peripheral issues.
1. The Local Plan must be based upon the actual status of Padden Brook
A fundamental concern is whether the Local Plan and its supporting evidence accurately identify the site’s existing planning and environmental status.
The documentary record published concerning Padden Brook states that the Council initially disputed the existence of protection affecting the land but subsequently acknowledged, through its correspondence, three separate forms of protection:
- Local Wildlife Site status;
- W1 woodland protection; and
- historic protected visual-amenity land associated with the 1963 permission.
This account is supported by the reproduction of an October 2024 Council response within the Padden Brook material.
I am not asking the Inspector to accept every interpretation contained in the published material.
Rather, I ask that the Council’s own underlying documents are examined and that the Local Plan evidence accurately records all relevant designations and planning constraints.
If the land is a Local Wildlife Site and is subject to a woodland designation, these matters should be clearly reflected in the evidence base and Policies Map.
2. Local Wildlife Site status
The Padden Brook material reports that Stockport Council’s October 2024 correspondence confirmed that the woodland is a Local Wildlife Site and falls under saved UDP Policy NE1.2.
This is significant because the woodland should not be treated merely as an area containing trees.
A Local Wildlife Site designation recognises ecological value.
The Council’s own Local Plan evidence recognises the importance of local ecological networks and the environmental value of woodlands and river corridors.
The Local Plan therefore needs to demonstrate that the ecological significance of Padden Brook has been properly considered.
3. W1 woodland protection
The reported Council correspondence also confirms the site’s W1 woodland designation.
This should be given proper weight when considering the effect of development or other land-use changes.
The current Stockport Local Plan contains a specific policy approach to trees and woodland. The proposed ENV 5 policy states that development should seek to avoid loss of, and minimise harm to, existing trees and woodland of visual or nature-conservation value. It also requires appropriate arboricultural assessment where development affects established woodland.
This is particularly relevant at Padden Brook because the site has not consisted simply of isolated trees.
The published photographic and documentary material describes a continuous established wooded area and records concerns about progressive clearance.
4. Cumulative tree loss
One of the most important issues is the cumulative effect of individual tree works and planning applications.
The Padden Brook record describes a sequence of tree works and applications over a period exceeding two years, including applications involving relatively small numbers of dwellings.
Even where each individual application is capable of being considered on its own merits, the Local Plan should consider the cumulative effect upon the woodland resource.
Otherwise there is a danger that:
individual loss → reduced woodland → altered baseline → further loss
becomes an incremental process in which the original character and ecological function of the woodland are progressively diminished.
The planning system should assess the cumulative effect rather than simply treating each individual tree removal as unrelated to the others.
5. Tree Preservation Order 376E
The existence of an active confirmed TPO is objective evidence that the Council considers the trees at Padden Brook worthy of protection.
Stockport’s official record confirms:
- TPO reference: 376E;
- name: Padden Brook, Romiley 2023;
- status: Active;
- date made: 16 May 2023;
- date confirmed: 16 November 2023.
This protection should be properly reflected in any planning assessment.
The Council should also demonstrate that the cumulative effect of permitted and proposed tree works is consistent with the purpose of the TPO and with the wider woodland policies of the Local Plan.
6. The retaining wall and land stability
A separate and potentially serious issue concerns the retaining wall adjoining Howard Close.
The Padden Brook documentation reproduces correspondence stating that structural engineers examined the retaining wall and advised that three sycamore trees adjacent to it should be removed because their roots were undermining the wall’s footings.
The same correspondence warned that if the wall failed, the footpath and road could subside, potentially resulting in road closure.
This should not be treated merely as a tree-management issue.
It raises a wider question of land stability and public safety.
The road and footway serve approximately two dozen homes, according to the published correspondence.
The Council should therefore establish, through appropriate engineering evidence:
- the current condition of the wall;
- its structural capacity;
- the ground conditions behind and beneath it;
- the effects of tree roots;
- the consequences of tree removal;
- the effects of surface-water runoff;
- the effects of any earthworks;
- the effects of construction activity;
- the effects of additional loading; and
- responsibility for long-term inspection and maintenance.
7. Surface water and drainage
The Padden Brook material also records observations of standing water and surface runoff close to the retaining wall.
I recognise that photographic evidence of standing water does not, by itself, establish the cause or extent of a flood risk.
It does, however, justify proper investigation.
Any planning framework affecting the site should therefore be supported by evidence addressing:
- existing drainage;
- surface-water flow paths;
- groundwater;
- soil conditions;
- the effect of vegetation removal;
- changes in ground levels;
- impermeable surfaces;
- exceedance flows; and
- potential effects on neighbouring land and infrastructure.
The relationship between drainage and land stability is particularly important where a retaining structure is already present.
8. Ecological impact
The ecological implications of woodland clearance should be assessed at the level of the habitat, rather than solely at the level of individual protected trees.
The published Padden Brook material describes the former woodland as a continuous established wildlife habitat and refers to protected species concerns.
Where development or clearance affects habitat, the Council should require appropriate ecological evidence identifying:
- protected species;
- priority habitats;
- nesting and breeding habitat;
- bat roosting potential;
- habitat connectivity;
- effects of lighting;
- construction disturbance;
- changes to drainage; and
- cumulative habitat loss.
Stockport itself identifies woodlands and river corridors as important ecological assets within the borough.
9. Biodiversity net gain is not a substitute for avoiding ecological harm
Biodiversity Net Gain should not be treated as a mechanism which automatically makes the loss of established woodland acceptable.
Stockport requires biodiversity information to be submitted as part of the planning process and states that the ecological context is important when determining how habitat should be retained or secured.
The relevant question should therefore be:
Can the development avoid or minimise harm to the existing ecological resource in the first place?
Only after that question has been properly addressed should mitigation, enhancement or compensation be considered.
10. Land stability and construction activity
The Padden Brook material records an image and account of mechanical excavation occurring on the wooded bank above the retaining wall.
I do not ask the Inspector to assume from this material alone that the works were unlawful.
The point is that where mechanical works, vegetation clearance and ground disturbance occur on a slope above a retaining structure already identified as presenting a potential subsidence risk, the Local Plan and any subsequent planning decision should require appropriate engineering evidence.
The relevant assessment should consider the combined effect of:
- vegetation removal;
- excavation;
- changes in soil structure;
- altered drainage;
- additional loading;
- machinery;
- retaining-wall stability; and
- construction activity.
11. Historic industrial use and potential contamination
The Padden Brook material also raises a separate question concerning the site’s historical use as a wire works and the possibility of associated historic contamination.
The material identifies potential contaminants associated with historic wire-working activity, but I emphasise that these are presented as a concern requiring investigation rather than as proof that contamination currently exists.
This is precisely why the matter should be investigated rather than assumed away.
If development is proposed on or near land with a potentially contaminative historic use, the Council should establish:
- the historic extent of the industrial activity;
- the nature of the former use;
- potential contaminants;
- soil and groundwater conditions;
- potential contaminant pathways;
- risks to residents;
- risks to surface water and groundwater; and
- whether earthworks could mobilise contaminants.
The presence of historical streams, culverts, wells, marshy ground or standing water would make understanding potential contaminant pathways particularly important, if confirmed by site investigation.
12. Planning history and enforcement
The site has an extensive planning and enforcement history.
The Padden Brook record identifies concerns relating to:
- a derelict butty van;
- its apparent subsequent use as a site office;
- a table and chairs;
- occupation and use of the land;
- tree works;
- woodland protection;
- land stability;
- and the retaining wall.
The Council’s enforcement position is a matter for the Council.
However, where there is a lengthy unresolved enforcement history, it is legitimate to ask whether the Local Plan evidence has properly taken account of the actual planning condition of the site.
The Council should identify clearly:
- what development is authorised;
- what development is alleged to be unauthorised;
- what enforcement investigations have taken place;
- what decisions have been made;
- and what remains unresolved.
13. The distinction between enforcement and plan-making
I recognise that an enforcement investigation and a Local Plan examination are separate processes.
The existence of an enforcement dispute does not automatically mean that development should be refused.
However, the two matters cannot be entirely disconnected where enforcement issues reveal potentially important information about the site’s physical condition, use or environmental constraints.
For example, evidence concerning land stability, protected woodland, drainage or historic use may be directly relevant to whether a site is suitable for future development.
The Local Plan evidence should therefore be based on the actual characteristics of the land, not simply its theoretical development potential.
14. Residential amenity
Any development or intensification at Padden Brook must properly consider the effect on existing residents.
This should include:
- construction noise;
- dust;
- vehicle movements;
- deliveries;
- parking;
- lighting;
- overlooking;
- privacy;
- loss of mature screening;
- visual intrusion;
- changes to outlook;
- surface-water effects;
- land-stability concerns; and
- emergency access.
The removal of established woodland may have consequences beyond biodiversity.
It can materially change the relationship between neighbouring houses and the development site.
15. Public safety and emergency access
The potential consequences of retaining-wall failure should be properly understood.
Where the Council’s own records or correspondence identify a potential risk of road or footway subsidence, the Council should be able to demonstrate that appropriate risk assessment has been undertaken.
The issue is particularly important because the structure serves an existing residential road and footway.
The appropriate question is not simply whether a failure has occurred.
It is whether the existing and proposed condition of the site has been demonstrated to be safe.
16. The problem of an artificially changing baseline
There is a fundamental planning issue here.
If woodland is progressively cleared and the remaining site is then assessed on the basis of its reduced vegetation, the resulting assessment may fail to recognise the environmental value which existed before the clearance.
The Council should therefore consider the site’s historical condition where this is relevant to understanding cumulative environmental effects.
The fact that part of the woodland has already been lost should not automatically reduce the weight given to the remaining woodland or justify further loss.
17. Soundness – whether the Local Plan is justified
Stockport’s current Regulation 19 consultation asks whether the Local Plan is justified and whether its policies and allocations are based on a robust and appropriate strategy.
In relation to Padden Brook, the Council should therefore demonstrate that its evidence base properly identifies:
- the Local Wildlife Site;
- W1 woodland;
- TPO 376E;
- ecological value;
- cumulative tree loss;
- land-stability issues;
- retaining-wall constraints;
- drainage;
- potential contamination;
- residential amenity; and
- planning/enforcement history.
If significant constraints are absent from the evidence base, or insufficiently assessed, there is a question as to whether the resulting policy approach is properly justified.
18. Soundness – whether the approach is effective
A Local Plan should be capable of being implemented.
Where development depends upon resolving substantial physical or environmental constraints, the Council should demonstrate that those constraints can realistically be addressed.
At Padden Brook this requires evidence on:
- retaining-wall stability;
- land stability;
- drainage;
- ecology;
- woodland;
- contamination, if confirmed;
- access;
- infrastructure; and
- the relationship between development and neighbouring homes.
It would not be sufficient simply to defer every significant constraint to a later planning application if the constraint is sufficiently fundamental to call the site’s suitability into question now.
19. Soundness – consistency with national policy
The National Planning Policy Framework requires the planning system to protect and enhance the natural environment and to take account of biodiversity and environmental impacts. The current NPPF also contains specific protections for irreplaceable habitats such as ancient woodland and ancient or veteran trees.
I am not asserting that the Padden Brook woodland is ancient woodland unless the Council’s evidence establishes that fact.
The point is that the national planning framework requires environmental constraints to be properly considered and that the presence of established woodland and a designated Local Wildlife Site is plainly relevant to that assessment.
20. Transparency and access to relevant evidence
The Padden Brook record documents a prolonged dispute concerning access to information about the site.
It records a Council decision in August 2026 to treat future Padden Brook FOI/EIR requests as vexatious and other communications concerning Padden Brook or the surrounding area as unreasonably persistent, with communications diverted to a dedicated inbox.
The Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman subsequently declined to investigate the complaint, citing lateness in relation to the underlying issues and concluding that an investigation into the communications restriction was unlikely to find fault.
I do not ask the Planning Inspector to overturn or re-determine the Ombudsman’s decision.
However, the existence of the communications dispute makes it particularly important that the planning evidence itself is complete, transparent and independently examinable.
The Inspector should therefore be able to identify the primary documents underpinning the site’s designation, planning history and physical constraints.
21. The Council’s own governance standards
The published Padden Brook material quotes Stockport’s own governance framework as requiring the Council to operate in a lawful, open, inclusive and honest manner and to manage risk effectively.
Again, this representation is not asking the Inspector to determine whether the Council has breached its governance framework.
Rather, the principle of effective risk management is directly relevant to a site where documentary evidence raises questions concerning:
- land stability;
- a retaining wall;
- surface water;
- protected woodland;
- ecological value; and
- potential development impacts.
The Council should be able to demonstrate how these risks have been identified and addressed.
22. Required evidence before further development is supported
I respectfully request that the following evidence be made available and considered.
Woodland and trees
- current BS 5837-compliant tree survey;
- Arboricultural Impact Assessment;
- Arboricultural Method Statement;
- assessment of cumulative tree loss;
- assessment of root protection areas;
- assessment of the relationship between trees and the retaining wall;
- woodland management proposals.
Ecology
- Local Wildlife Site assessment;
- ecological appraisal;
- protected-species surveys;
- habitat assessment;
- assessment of ecological connectivity;
- assessment of cumulative habitat loss;
- biodiversity net-gain calculations and baseline.
Engineering
- independent structural assessment of the retaining wall;
- geotechnical investigation;
- slope-stability assessment;
- ground-condition assessment;
- assessment of the consequences of tree removal;
- construction-phase stability assessment.
Drainage
- existing drainage survey;
- surface-water assessment;
- groundwater assessment;
- flood-risk assessment where required;
- exceedance-flow assessment;
- assessment of the effect of earthworks and vegetation clearance.
Contamination
If the historic wire-works use is confirmed:
- desk-based contamination assessment;
- intrusive investigation where necessary;
- soil and groundwater sampling;
- remediation strategy where required;
- assessment of contaminant migration pathways.
Planning history
- complete planning history;
- enforcement history;
- identification of authorised development;
- identification of unresolved matters;
- explanation of how those matters have informed the Local Plan evidence.
23. Request for reconsideration
For the reasons above, I respectfully request that the Council reconsider the planning approach to Padden Brook and ensure that the site is not treated as suitable for further development without first establishing, through robust evidence, that:
- the site’s protected woodland and Local Wildlife Site status have been fully recognised;
- TPO 376E has been properly taken into account;
- cumulative tree and habitat loss has been assessed;
- the retaining wall is structurally adequate;
- the surrounding land is demonstrably stable;
- surface-water and drainage issues have been properly assessed;
- potential contamination from historic uses has been investigated where appropriate;
- ecological impacts have been fully assessed;
- neighbouring residential amenity can be protected;
- access and highway implications are acceptable;
- the site’s planning and enforcement history has been properly considered; and
- the development approach is genuinely justified, effective and consistent with national planning policy.
CONCLUSION
Padden Brook should not be treated as an ordinary development site.
The available evidence indicates a site with a confirmed Tree Preservation Order, Local Wildlife Site status, W1 woodland protection, a history of planning and enforcement concerns, significant established woodland, questions concerning a retaining wall and land stability, surface-water concerns and potential historic land-use issues.
The purpose of this representation is not to assert that every allegation contained in residents’ correspondence or published material has been proven.
Rather, it is to identify matters which are sufficiently significant that they should be properly investigated, documented and reflected in the Local Plan evidence before the site is treated as suitable for further development or intensification.
The Council’s own records confirm the continuing legal status of TPO 376E. Its reported October 2024 correspondence also confirms important environmental and planning designations affecting the woodland.
The existence of these designations, together with the physical issues identified above, means that the site requires a comprehensive assessment.
I therefore respectfully ask the Council and, if the matter proceeds to examination, the appointed Planning Inspector to ensure that the Padden Brook evidence base is complete and that the Local Plan does not rely upon an assessment which understates or fails to take account of the site’s environmental, structural, planning and cumulative constraints.
In particular, I request that the Council demonstrates that its proposed approach to Padden Brook is justified by robust evidence, effective and deliverable in practice, and consistent with national planning policy. Where that evidence is absent or incomplete, the relevant policy or allocation should be reconsidered before the Local Plan is submitted for examination.
You have already been given all the evidence, but ignored it.
Sheila
